Updated Sunday 15 May, 2011 12:18 PM

   Headlines  |  Alternate Histories  |  International Edition


Home Page

Announcements 

Alternate Histories

International Edition

List of Updates

Want to join?

Join Writer Development Section

Writer Development Member Section

Join Club ChangerS

Editorial

Chris Comments

Book Reviews

Blog

Letters To The Editor

FAQ

Links Page

Terms and Conditions

Resources

Donations

Alternate Histories

International Edition

Alison Brooks

Fiction

Essays

Other Stuff

Authors

If Baseball Integrated Early

Counter-Factual.Net

Today in Alternate History

This Day in Alternate History Blog



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A History of the Roman Caliphate

 

 

Musa being returned to Damascus, the Caliph Abd-el Melek asked of him about his conquests, saying "Now tell me about these Franks---what is their nature?"

"They," replied Musa, "are a folk right numerous, and full of might: brave and impetuous in the attack, but cowardly and craven in event of defeat."

"And how has passed the war betwixt them and thyself? Favorably or the reverse?"

"The reverse? No, by Allah and the prophet!" spoke Musa. "Never has a company from my army been beaten. And never have the Moslems hesitated to follow me when I have led them; though they were twoscore to fourscore."

Conversation between Musa, conqueror of the Visigoth kingdom, and the Umayadd Caliph Ab-el Melek.

 

“A victorious line of march had been prolonged above a thousand miles from the rock of Gibraltar to the bank of the Loire; the repetition of an equal space would have carried the Saracens to the confines of Poland and the Highlands of Scotland; the Rhine is not more impassable than the Nile or Euphrates, and the Arabian fleet might have sailed without a naval combat into the mouth of the Thames. Perhaps the interpretation of the Koran would now be taught in the schools of Oxford, and her pupils might demonstrate to a circumcised people the sanctity and truth of the revelation of Muhammad”-Edward Gibbon, 1776

 

The year is 732 AD. The armies of the Caliph are unstoppable; Egypt, the Holy Land, North Africa, and Spain have fallen. The Muslims believe that all of the world shall be a part of Dar-Islam, including, as is prophesized, Constantinople; only the use of Greek fire has saved Byzantium from invasion.  It is said that even the capital of the Roman Empire shall one day be ruled by a Caliph.

 

Now, the armies of Islam have been ever victorious. Sweeping out of the deserts of Arabia, under the banner of the prophet, swept out of Arabia in the early 7th century. To make a long story short, they arrived at a very opportune time; the Byzantine Empire and the Persians had just finished a very costly and bloody war. The Arab armies were victorious in Syria and Egypt, and the Muslim faith attracted many Monophysite Christians, who were persecuted by Byzantium for their heretical ideas.  By 711 they

stood on the Pillars of Gibraltar, ruled possibly the world’s largest empire.

 

Across the straits lay the Visigoth Kingdom. It was, like the Ostrogoth Kingdom of Italy, fairly civilized; it was stronger, for example, than the Frankish kingdom in the North, because the Visigoths did not divide their lands up among the sons of the king. The Spanish were Catholics, and the Visigoth king was elected by the nobles and bishops. He was elected either in Toledo or on the site of the previous king’s death, and he had to swear to uphold the laws of the realm. The Nobles were divided into the duces (dux, or duke), and the comes, or counts. These were based on the military titles. In comparison, however, there was the Church. The clergy were, as in much of the medieval world, the largest landowners and the most powerful political figure. There was no standing military; the comes and duces brought their own levies to battle.

 

The population was about four million, and there was little to no long distance trade. In effect, it was a pretty typical medieval kingdom. Literacy was rare; scholarship was restricted to the Bible.

 

Now, according to legend, Count Julian of Ceuta, which was in Muslim lands, asked his Muslim overlords to avenge the rape of his daughter by King Roderick of the Visigoths. While a legend, it probably does portray the dislike that the people had for Roderick.  Roderick had taken power in a coup in 710, and defeated an army led by the rival claimant. By 717, the time was ripe for an invasion, and the governor of Tangier, with ten thousand men, crossed the states into Gibraltar.  The Muslims win a few battles, and effectively crush the Visigoths, who were divided in a civil war at the time. By 717, the peninsula is in the hands of the  Muslims.

 

France is the new battleground. The governor of Al-Andalus, the Muslim name for Spain, has been leading raids into France, and each raid has become progressively larger. Charles Martel, Mayor of the Palace, raises an army to beat back the infidel. The Mayor of the Palace is, by this point, the unofficial King of the Franks. The Muslims are led by Abd al-Rahman, the governor. After defeating the Duke of Aquitane in battle, Al-Rahman marches to sack Tours. By this point, Al-Rahman has conquered Aquitane; or, looking at it another way, he has looted the region and destroyed even the semblance of government.

 

The battle took place in October of 732, although we do not know the precise date. The Muslims were maneuvered by Martel into fighting a battle in an indefensible position, but even so, nearly won.  The heavy infantry of the franks was indeed formidable; but as history has shown, heavy infantry can only beat cavalry if they do not waver. They didn’t, and the Muslim raids ended. 

 

But even this battle was a near run. Despite having slight numerical superiority, and a superior position, the Franks were battered heavily; the Muslims only lost when their general, Al-Rahman, was killed in battle, and according to the few, sketchy accounts we do have, Charles expected the Arabs to fight another day; they withdrawed in the night.

 

Now, there are several different ways at looking at this battle. It is only fair to discuss them here. Details are sketchy (this was the dark ages), but Christiaian chronicles record this as a major battle, saving Europe from an infidel invasion. Muslim chronicles record this as a minor defeat of a raiding party. The length of the battle also differs; the Muslims say it lasted two days, the Christians seven. IN reality, the battle appears to have consisted of several days skirmishing before the decisive clash.

 

The fact that it was led by the governor in person indicates that this was more than just a raid; the establishment of a Muslim governor in Avignon does so as well. It was certainly he largest raid in the history of Al-Andalus; numbers are put around thirty thousand by modern historians. A key factor was also that the Muslims were waging war against Duke Eudo; he had supported rebels in Al-Andalus, and now he was to pay the price. So let’s make him pay the price, along with Martel, and change the outcome at Poiters.

 

So, let’s change the battle’s outcome.

 

The POD: An arrow flying from the Muslim cavalry hits Charles Martel, instead of missing. He dies shortly thereafter. The heavy infantry flee off of their hilltop position, leaving them exposed to the charges from the Arab cavalry, which doomed their Visigoth and Byzantine counterparts. Most of the army is killed; The Muslims go on to sack Tours.

 

The Immediate after effects: Well, Charles reign after the battle was spent consolidating his realm. Here, that doesn’t happen. The Duke of Friesland (part of the Netherlands), Bobo, rose up in revolt under, but was suppressed by Charles two years later. In This TL, with the best Frankish troops dead on a road to Tours, this won’t happen. In fact, the Frankish realm was very unstable; the Saxons and Bavarians rose up against the Franks repeatedly. Here, it’s quite likely they will maintain their paganism and independence for a good while longer.

 

732- Al-Rahman sacks Tours, and returns home with disgusting amounts of loot, most of it from the Catholic Church.  He also, unlike the leaders of previous raids, sets up Muslim strongholds in Bordeaux and Nimes, in France.

 

733- An even larger expedition is organized by Al-Rahman. This army is intended to be one of conquest; the holy war is to be carried out against “The Franks”.  Al-Rahman receives an interesting offer around this time, which complicates things a bit.

 

The Duke Eudo of Aquitane, you see, had two sons. Hatto and Hunold. But the Duchy was not divided, as per Frankish custom. Pepin, the King of the Franks, gave all of it to Hatto (as in OT). This was because Hunold was accused of cowardice for his failure to fight at Tours, when in reality he was rallying the Aquitanian soldiers in the aftermath of a decisive defeat at he hands of Al-Rahman.

 

Note: This seems, at first glance, implausible to many. But historically, the Franks did divide land up amongst brothers; situations like this happened dozens of times throughout history. In fact, these brothers did rise up in revolt against Charles Martel.

 

Al-Rahman agrees, and over the next several years the armies of Al-Andalus thunder into Gaul. By 740, they have taken Aquitane, Provence, Burgundy, and raid to the Rhine. The Frankish king Pepin makes a treaty with the new governor of Al-Andalus, Abd Al-Malik. According to the treaty, the Frankish Kingdom is reduced to the land across from the Seine. Malik agrees to this, because as every one knows, what’s beyond the Rhine? Nothing but pagans and barren wastelands. Hatto protests, but doesn’t have much choice. Mayor Pepin consents, losing much of Burgundy, all of Provence, Aquitane,  and some of Nuestria itself, the heartland of the Franks.

 

Now, there are two possible ways at looking at what happens in the north. The first is the idea of a rebound: The Franks, fleeing the Muslims, invade Germany faster than in OTL. The other option depends on how badly the franks lose at Tours. If they are badly defeated, as they were here, it’s possible their empire collapses. Consensus seems to be that they would fight dozens of rebellions, as in OTL, and probably collapse.

 

Now, the Muslims, under Malik have a problem. They’ve conquered tons of land, but it is lightly populated. How to defend it?

Malik, looks at other examples. Along the Marches in Northern Spain and along the Byzantine border, there are local lords who have power for the defense of the region. They also swear an oath of loyalty to their ruler, and help defend the border. Why not expand it into Gaul? More paractically, without such promises, no one would want ot enter into the desolate land that is Gaul.

 

Malik goes one step further With nobles in Aquitane and Burgundy swearing fealty and becoming Muslims, he decides to reestablish the Roman military system. There are now to be, in the west, the “Wali”; a military leader for a region. The “Wali” will help to raise men from his region to raid the nearby lands, provide soldiers for the jihad, and so on and so forth. The Walis receive the caliph’s grudging approval, but over time the “Walis” will be very valuable in subduing France, and raiding. Several comes are also established, many of them Franksh Muslims. The Walis will work both ways, of course. In Gaul and elsewhere, their rule will be rather chaotic.

 

The Caliph is not pleased; it has been a tradition of Islam to emphatically not give soldiers their own land, but settle them in towns. But Malik is able to convince the Caliph, via  a series of letters, that this is for the best, because it turns the new Muslims will now fight to defend their land, and, more importantly, there’s not much the Caliph can do about it, thousands of miles away.  

 

The conversion is fairly rapid, for materialistic reasons. If lands are conquered by force, they become the property of the Muslims, and the proceeds from the properties were to be used by the Museums as their ruler saw fit. If the lands were taken peacefully, in what is known as sulhan, the lands were the property of the inhabitants which would pass to Muslims only by inheritance of purchase. In addition, taxation is much lower for Muslims (according to records form the time, 70% of the government’s funds came from the poll tax on Christians and Jews).

 

What follows shortly is a massive civil war in both the land of the Franks, and in Al-Andalus.

 

In the land  of the Franks, you see, the new mayor  of the Palace, related to Charles, Pepin, rules. His sons, Pepin and Carloman, divided the realms between them. But there was no king for the Franks.  This is combined with revolts in Alemannia (Western South German, and Eastern France). The Duke of Bavaria is joined with the Duke of Friesland and Saxony. To complicate things even more, the bastard of Pepin (the former Mayor, not this Pepin) rallies men under “the true King”, Childeric III. The brothes are able warriors, but the wars would continue until Pepin’s son, Charlemagne, took over, and would rule only the core Frankish territories.

 

While such a situation would appear ripe for an attack by the Muslims, in reailty the border is pushed back, with a no man’s land from the Rhine to the Loire.

 

In Al-Andalus, the Berbers of North Africa rose in revolt. This was primarily caused by the imposition of a kharaj (land tax) on the Berbers and make them second class citizens to help pay for the Syrian army which was the strength of the Caliphate. Also helping, of course, is the fact that children, boys and girls alike, are taken for the harems of the Umayyad elite. Eventually, the whole North African coast (the Maghreb) slipped from the Caliphate’s hands. A new army is raised in Syria to subdue the rebel Berbers, and thus, in 741 the army reaches Morocco. The army is defeated by the Berbers, and the survivors flee north to Ceuta. They appeal to the governor of Al-Andalus for help, but are refused.

 

Thus, events continue. In 741, there are Berber uprisings in Al-Andalus, and the armies of the Caliphate are driven out of the northwest. The Berbers march south towards Cordoba and the governor was unable to resist them. Finally, the governor of Al-Andalus, ‘Abd al-Malik, agrees to transport the army of Syrians across the straits. In 742, they cross into Al-Andalus, and defeats the Berbers. But after the battle, the Syrians do not want to leave, because  here they can “live like kings”. Relations between the army and Malik broke down, and a coup occurred, leaving Balj, leader of the Syrian army, in control. The Arab elite launched a counterattack, which also features some Frankish infantry. The Franks switch sides to the Syrians for greater pay, and the Syrians retain possession of Cordoba.

 

In 743 a new governor is sent to Al-Andalus, one Abu’l-Khattar al-Husam. He was a Yemeni aristocrat from Damascus, the capital of the caliphate, and tried to solve the problems of the province.

 

Abu’s solution decides to settle the Syrians in Al-Andalus. Each jund was settled in a different area, and the regions are Granada, Malaga, Archidona, Sidonia, Seville, Niebla, Jaen, and the jund of Egypt, finally, receives Arles. They are given a third of the revenue of the lands to support themselves, and paid the government a fixed sum. In return, the Syrians wage war for the emir in Al-Andalus.

 

The consequences are long-lasting. Al-Andalus and Al-Aquitane, the Arabic name for their land in Gaul, are henceforth to have a greater Arabic population; in Gaul, the Berbers are almost unknown. Also important is that many of the soldiers in the junds had a long-standing loyalty to the Umayyad family.

 

Unfortunately, there were also difficulties. The introduction of the soldiers changed the balance between the Qays and Yemen, two Muslim tribes from southern Arabia. The two tribes have had a long and bitter conflict, and the enslavement of Yemenis in the aftermath of the Berber revolt did not improve the situation.  The new governor favored the Yemenis, and the Qays could not afford this. They chose a rival governor, Al-Sumayl, who was fanatically devoted to the Qays. The Qays are joined by two former Yemeni tribes, the Lakhm and Judham. These two tribes had long been settled in Syria, and felt that they had more in common with the Qays. The coalition rose in revolt and in 745 defeated Abu, who was taken prisoner. He’s rescued, but during the chaos several men from the Qays and Lakhms try to become governor. Al-Sumayl, the leader of the Qays’s cause, produces an outside candidate, Yusuf b. Abd Al- Rahman.

 

Yusuf b. Abd Al-Rahman was a good choice. He was old, and al-Sumayl could expect him to be a useful tool. He was a descendent of a hero of the Muslim conquest of North Africa, and was from the tribe of the Prophet. Yusuf defeats the Yemenis with Al-Sumayl, assisted by some of the Frankish Muslim infantry. Yusuf begins to feel increasingly secure, and the collapse of the Umayyad Caliphate means that Yusuf is the independent ruler of Al-Andalus.

 

During this period, the border with the northern Christian holdouts in Spain stabilizes. Alfonso I, the Christian King, was able to establish outposts on the Duero plain and raid further south.  Yusuf believes things are shaping up pretty well.

 

Then comes Ad Al-Rahman I, to establish the Umayyad Emirate.

 

The Coming of the Umayyads

 

For half a century, the Umayyads ruled from Sind and Sarmarqand in the east to Al-Andalus in the west, but there was always opposition. Apparently some Muslims were upset with the idea of a hereditary monarchy based on a family who had been among Mohammed’s early enemies. Starting in 747, the Abbasid dynasty took over the Muslim world, which swept the Umayyads and their Syrian supporters from power. Most of the Umayyads were killed, but a few were able to escape.

 

An example of one would be Abd Al-Rahman b. Mu’awiya (Al-Rahman is also a title, by the way). He was a grandson of the Caliph Hisham, who died in 743. AFter escaping to Tunis, in North Africa, he is forced to leave by the governor, and flees to the Syrian Junds in Al-Andalus.

 

When he arrived in Al-Andalus, he tried to attract the support of Al-Sumayl, who refused him. Abd. Al-Rahman then turned to the Yemenis, and by 756 had recruited an army of walis from Gaul, jundis, and Umayyad citizen-soldiers, or mawali. The last, of course, are the least important.

 

Now, I believe that it is important to note what Junds were. In Syria, they were districts from which the Muslim armies were recruited; in Al-Andalus, they were groups of soldiers who collected rent from their Christian serfs. The treasury, the army, and taxation were decentralized, with most of the junds having their own autonomous control over it.

 

(Note: Would it be more realistic to have the junds become like barons, or more like the Byzantine soldiers and cataphracts? The latter would be much more interesting (Mounted knights of The Caliph marching from Rome), but not necessarily realistic).  Abd-Al Rahman defeats Al-Sumayl and Yusuf, and in June of 756, entered Cordoba, the capital of the emirate. This was not the end of his attempt to gain power, but only the beginning. After the first year, he removed the name of the Abbasid Caliph from Friday prayers, a dramatic step, because it challenges their authority to become caliph. (And before anyone asks, this did happen historically).

 

The northern walis continue their usual raiding and pillaging, while the Franks from Nuestria respond in kind, although Arles and Marseilles have begun to develop into respectable ports. Conversion along the border towards Islam increases, as the Franks lose ground in the East before the Saxons and Bavarians.

 

Abd Al-Rahman is followed by other Umayyads, and they build up a following. Abd Al-Rahman began defeating rebels throughout Iberia, and lands were confiscated from the Christians. But a good many Umayyads and their supporters are settled in Al-Aquitane,

 

Abd Al-Rahman’s first problem was to destroy the power of his predecessors, Yusuf and Al-Sumayl, who remained in the field. Yusuf escapes to Merida, where he raises a large army of Berbers. He was finally defeated and murdered near Toledo, by a Frank, in 659.

 

Toledo holds out for seven more years; and it is not until 764 that Al-Rahman can send his army against the city. 

 

Other threats appear as well. Jafar Al-Mansur (Jafar ever victorious), the Abbasid Caliph, convinces Al-Ala b. Al-Mughith of Southern Portugal to fight against Abd Al-Rahman. With covert support, Al-Ala raises an army, and clashes with the emir.  The battle took place in Carmona, high on a hill. In the most desperate battle of his reign, the caliph’s army is nearly defeated. The troops of the jund, however, turn the tide, and the head of the defeated rebel is taken to Medina and left outside the caliph’s tent. Al-Rahman’s troops array themselves in a square on the hill, and “are like a wall of stone”.

 

Things still aren’t over. It is fortunate for Abd that the Franks are disunited still, otherwise he  might have lost much of Gaul.  Abd Al-Rahman has decided to assert his power over the junds.

 

The junds in Al-Andalus, you see, have leaders who are chosen by their followers, and could make war or alliances as they saw fit. The Walis and Junds are very close, incidentally, and he has to step lightly in some areas. When he appoints the Umayyad Abd Al-Malik b. Umar b. Marwan as the governor of Marseilles, this was resented by the wali, who felt it was an enroachment on their power.

 

Abd Al-Rahman refuses to change his mind, and one Charles al-Matari, in Aquitane, raises the banner of revolt. Several other walis join him, as do the junds near Cordoba, who resent the emir’s confiscation of land and its transfer to the Umayyads, not to themselves. A surprise attack takes Seville, and the Andalusi revolution begins.

 

I think it’s time to take a little break from the TL. The Umayyad Emirate is at a crossroads. In OTL, it became a strongly centralized, politically unstable state when the junds were brought to heel. With no say, they did not keep up their military strength (why bother?), and were replaced by Berber mercenaries.

 

Here, though, their revolt does not fail. They have the assistance of the walis from Gaul and Al-Aquitane, who come south to join them. After all, if the Emir tries to take over the power of taxation from the junds, then he will surely do the same thing to them, at some point. The Emir’s city of Narbonne falls in 767, and the Umayyad governor flees at night on horseback. Al-Rahman crushes the revolt at Seville, and retakes the city in 678, but the rebellion continues.  A Berber, Shaqya ibn Abd Al-Wahid, claiming to be related to the Alids, rose the banner of revolt near Cuenca. He dominates the sparsely inhabited uplands.

 

Zaragoza is another rebellious region. The lords of Zaragoza and the Ebro valley resist Umayyad attempts to take their city, as a tradition of local autonomy is well established.

 

Finally, in  772, the Emir is forced to sign a treaty. Upon the Koran, he swears to respect the rights and privileges of the junds and walis, “and so it shall be for my sons, and the sons of my sons.” After generous concessions in terms of privileges (the junds especially benefit, in the form of additional revenues), the walis and junds become supporters of their new emirate. They both agree that the greater threat comes from raids of the Asturians, and the revolts of the Berbers. Also a key role is that while they know they cannot defeat Al-Rahman, as things are, neither can Al-Rahman gain control.

 

Ultimately, it will be the junds who slay Shaqya, in the bitter warfare of the north. 

 

Meanwhile, in the land of the Franks (The Christian ones), things are heating up. Another round of civil war breaks out in 772, when Charles, Carloman’s son,  tries to take the lands of his father’s brother, Pepin. Pepin’s two sons wage war against him. They rally support, and some of the Walis join them as mercenaries.

 

With the destruction of the Alid revolt of Shayqa, Abd Al-Rahman finally can catch his breath.  Abd Al-Rahman would die peacefully, on October 7, 788. The Umayyad emirate had weathered the storm, and was a permanent force in the West.

 

Al-Italiya

 

Primogeniture had not yet been established in Firanji (The Muslim name for Europe), and Al-Andalus was no exception. Abd Al-Rahman had made it clear that his son Hisham, who was born in Cordoba in 757, should be his successor. Hisham has the support of the Junds, and Suleyman of the Berbers, and according to legend, the Emir told his chancellor to acknowledge whoever reached Cordoba first. Hisham won by several days, and Suleyman fled to the Berber city of Grenada. In a battle near the city, Suleyman was defeated, with the help of the junds, and is exiled to North Africa, with sixty thousand dinars.

 

Hisham is distraught in the aftermath, especially at how close to civil war the country came. He will make every effort to support his first born son, and in the meantime he subdues a minor revolt in the marches with the Christians near Zargaroza.

 

Hisham has greater plans. He is the first Umayyad to actively pursue the title of Caliph.

 

But how to get the title? In OTL, the Emir of Al-Andalus claimed it in the 9th century, but that was with resources on par with Byzantium and the other Muslim empires. Here, that’s not the case. Hisham decides that he will put aside the idea of Caliph until he has fulfilled the duties of a Caliph. One of those duties is the jihad against the unbelievers.

 

He could try to invade across the Rhine, into the land of the Franks; but while they are divided and weak, being pushed back by Saxon invasions, there isn’t much glory for Allah in subduing them. And the climate is awful, although there are a fair number of converts in Nuestria. Apparently the Franks are beginning to realize that Christ is obviously only a prophet, or he would have not let them lose so much land to the pagans.

 

There is another choice, however. The Christians still obey the Pope, who resides in Rome, and has been encouraging the Lombards to invade Aquitane. If he were to invade the Lombard Kingdom and principalities in Italy, and took Rome, no one could deny that he is the Caliph.  So his reasoning goes, at any rate. And since Rome is under Lombard suzerainty after its conquest in the 770’s, there is no one to stop him. The Byzantines, perhaps; but they are preoccupied with wars against Muslims in the East.

 

The final provocation comes when the Lombard pirates, from Corsica, attack Marseilles. This marks the beginning of the conquest of Al-Italiya.

 

On a chilly April day in 791, the war begins. Frank infantry, as well as cavalry, some of whom use stirrups, from the lands in Gaul, invade from the north. The Junds also join,  hoping for land for their many sons. Lombard resistance is crushed in a battle near Ravenna, which had fallen to the Lombards several years earlier. Rome falls after a nine months siege, and the Emir, in person, enters the city. The wadjis begin converting the people of Italy through the time-tested methods, and a few actually penetrate into the realms of the Maygars, which is largely pagan.

 

Where is the Byzantine Empire? The Emperor, Constantine, is but a child; his mother is the real power behind the throne, and she is paying the Eastern Caliphate Tribute. The Emperor gained full power in 790, but the Empire has threats close to home. Irene prefers to give tribute to the Arabs and Bulgars, solidifying her rule in the empire. She does this, to a great degree of success; the tribute she gives Hisham lets him build the Emir’s palace, outside of Rome, but he does not invade Sicily.  The Umayyad invasion fleet was destroyed in a battle using Greek fire in 799, and events at home had caused problems for Emir

 

Hisham had died, you see, in 796. Historians remain divided over whether or not he was truly preparing to become caliph; he was preparing for an announcement during Ramadan, after all, and it was only a heart attack that prevented him from making it.  His firstborn son succeeded him, who was known as Al-Hakam. Al-Hakam was accepted as the Emir but the Abbasids were, naturally, against this, because Hakam was the more competent of his sons. They support Hisham’s brother, Suleyman, in raising a revolt. Suleyman spent four years wandering through Al-Andalus, building up support. Suleyman was finally executed by a leader of the junds, in 800, outside of Bordeaux.

Despite this glorious start, Al-Hakam found the emirates too unwieldy. He moved the capital to Rome in 803, and in 805, there was an attempted coup against him, inspired by Cordoban notables who feared a loss of influence. Al-Hakam discovered the coup, and 72 of them were executed in what was known as “The Day of the Moat”, because the bodies were tossed in the moat.  This horrified many of the walis and leaders of the junds, who were aghast that their Emir would do this.

The Emir continues with his wars of conquest in the Mediterranean, taking Sardinia and conquering the Balearic chain. But the reign of the Emir will be remembered more for the effects of his acts. First, he declared that wine drinking is permissible, as is all alcohol consumption, save for date wine. His reign also witnesses the beginnings of the Commercial revolution, as the near-total transformation of the Mediterranean into a Muslim lake brings about an amazing increase in the volume of trade. Genoa, Barcelona, and eventually, Venezia will be the chief Muslim ports for the western Caliphate.

Part III.5: Olaf, Prophet of Baldr.  

“They stink… they drink meade, and eat pork. Nothing of value could ever come from them.”- Ibn Hassan, speaking of the Norse traders in Bordeaux.

Olaf of Denmark was born in approximately 799 AD. His life was off to an uninspiring start, and he joined with Grimir, King of Denmark, in their war against the heathen Friesans.  It was probably during the raids of Grimir, who launched armadas numering over two hundred ships, that Olaf began receiving his visions.

Demographic forces were propelling the Norsemen outward, looking for gold, slaves, and, most importantly, land.

The Religion of the West

“They hold, on the other hand, however, that it is man who determines his own affairs, without any interference on the part of Allah, either in these affairs of men or of any of the deeds of animals. ... Furthermore, they agreed in the view that nothing in the acts of his servants, which Allah did not command or forbid, was willed by him”

The Muslim Historian Ibn- Rassan, writing of the Western Sect.

Hisham had begun, in the 790’s, to hire Mu'tazilite thinkers from the East, especially Baghdad. This was part of his attempts to make the capital in Rome as cultured as Baghdad, but it had interesting effects.

Where the Mu’tazilites of the East fell out of disfavor with the common people, the great western thinker, Balj, was able to simplify the doctrine to the common people, in essence by dumbing it down. According to the Baljites, “We (Allah)  showed him the Way: whether he be grateful or ungrateful (rests on his will”. The Koran’ was created by those who had the influence of Allah, but as it was made by humans, there was potential for error in the Koran. This radical idea was ruthlessly suppressed by the wadjis, but continually rose up. In different parts of Firanji.   In part because there was never any serious opposition to the Mu’tazilies/Baljites, The Baljite school of thought would triumph in the west, and men would hold that the route to Allah was through logic and reason.

Al-Hakam’s reign would also see a war with the Bavarians. Their king, Pepin,  sought to conquer Italy from the infidel, beginning the centuries of war between the Muslims and Christians. The war continues, on and off, with the Walis performing decently, and the junds establishing themselves in Al-Italiya., including in Milan and Firenze. Attempts to invade Bavaria are halted, thanks to the destruction of a Muslim army in the mountains.  The caliph raises taxes to fund the conquest, but this angered many of the nobles. He was preparing for the invasion of Bavaria when War of  Laws occurred.

The Caliph vs. The Walis

“With the aid of Allah governing Our Empire which was delivered to Us by His Celestial Majesty, We carry on war successfully. We adorn peace and maintain the Constitution of the State, and have such confidence in the protection of Allah that We do not depend upon Our arms, or upon Our soldiers, or upon those who conduct Our Wars, or upon Our own genius, but We solely, place Our reliance upon the providence of the Architect of the Ages, from which are derived the elements of the entire world and their disposition throughout the globe..”

Al-Hakam would earn the title “The Just”, despite the instability of his later reign. To vie with Byzantium for control of the Balkans, and to asset his claims against the Abbasids, Al-Hakam began implementing the Roman legal code, to help prove that he is the successor to the Roman Empire. The Muslims never had the fascination with he Roman Empire that others had, but they certainly viewed it as important, especially the Mu’tazilites.

Most of his laws are a based on the Byzantine justice system under Justinian, the Corpus Juris Civilis, with modifications for Islam. The death penalty, for instance, is much more common, although polygamy is not a crime (obviously) This infuriates the imams. While everyone acknowledges that the Byzantine Empire is a cultural equal of the Sultanate of Rome, that’s the law of the infidel Christians. Equally important is that this develops a class of scholars who are not dependent on Islam. And, finally, Al-Hakam declares that he is the Caliph.

So who does support it? The merchants of the coastal cities do, surprisingly. The system, for whatever its cons, has a greater uniformity than some of the religious law, which isn’t technically Qu’ranic, either. The walis also do, to a degree.  They reason (correctly) that they could use this system against him.

But, unfortunately, the Emirates have trouble digesting these changes.  Raising a navy is an expensive task, and the Caliph had been raising taxes that were “UnKoranic”. In reality, these taxes had been being collected by the walis, junds, and lords of the marches for a century, and they wanted to keep them. Combined with the encouragement from the wadjis, this led to a massive revolt against the Caliph, led by one Bobo Al-Mansur, a wali from northern Gaul, in 818.  Bobo gains support from many of the imams, and marches off to face the Caliph.

The Walis launch an invasion into Italiya, but pull back in the face of a threat from the junds. The junds of Al-Andalus, and the ones in Al-Italiya, have joined forces in support of the king. So has the small, yet rather impressive navy.  The civil war lasts six years, the longest single civil war in Andalusian history. There were of course, longer periods of unrest, bout those were periods of different civil wars.

In 819, the armies of the Emir invade Provence. Many of the junds defect, when Bobo and the nobles offer better terms, including land in Al-Italiya. This leads to fighting in Catalonia, where Al-Hakam’s army is defeated.

The destruction of his field army causes Hakam to turn a move he had long hoped to avoid. He begins hiring Berber mercenaries.

In Southern France, the Berber mercenaries prove effective; initially. But they run into the walls of the Franks, who stand, according to one survivor, “Like a wall of steel”.  In 820, the rebel lords smash the Emir’s army at the battle of Arles, confirming that heavy infantry are always superior to cavalry, provided they stand.  Disgusted, the Emir uses his money to hire armies of junds, who fight against the Franks in eastern Iberia. At the battle of Tortosa, in 822, the Emir’s jund army defeats the rebel, jund army.

Coincidentally, many of the defeated switch sides, a trait which is common in all battles of the war. The walis and caliph both recruit from the defeated armies, or ransom the captives.

 Finally, more due to the distance involved than anything else, Al-Hakam realizes that he cannot conquer everyone. If he does not come to a truce, he realizes that he cannot be everywhere at once. He finally agrees to a peace, which comes about in 825, and meets with the leading walis in Genoa for Ramadan.  The Caliph is also worried about the strange Northerners who have started burning the cities of his Caliphate.

The agreement states that in return for acknowledging Al-Hakam as the leader of Dar-Al-Islam, spiritually, the Caliph’s is not infallible temporally. The Caliph may control the minting of money, but he may only tax the Walis with taxes that are based on the Qu’ran. The Walis are free to raise money however they please. The rights of the cities to trade freely in the Empire are protected, and they may not be subject to dues when traveling from one part of the caliphate to another.  The walis maintain control over certain taxes. Al-Hakam is able to gain one benefit from the agreement. He is guaranteed as the Caliph of Dar-Al-Islam.

This was a move that the Umayyads had been moving to for many years. Since their consolidation in Rome, they had been styling themselves “The Sons of the Romans and the Caliphs”., and Al-Hakam had become aware that in order to keep the walis in line, he needed the title. Future historians would speculate that, given what happened, he would have preferred to remain a son of a Caliph, but he could not go back on his decision. The only ones who still protest are the walis, notably Ali of Tortosa, but he would die of grief in his sleep, covered by his pillows.

Al-Hakam is also able to get one more form of taxation in. The walis must raise their levies in order to fight for the Caliplh, when needed; but they must be up to a certain standard, devised by the Caliph and his administrators. If the men are not, then the walis must pay a tax, so that the Caliph can raise the men on his own.

The Northmen

"a furare normannorum libera nos, Domine”

            “From the rage of the northmen keep us, Oh lord”- Christian prayer, 10th century

“[They]  are the filthiest of God's creatures. They do not wash after discharging their natural functions, neither do they wash their hands after meal. They drink foul liquids, sacrifice to pagans, and are enemies of all that is good and pure. The Vikings cannot be threatened with the promise of hell; they live there.”-Ibn Fadlan, speaking of the Vikings

Just as things were looking dark for Christendom, the situation worsened. Beginning in the 790’s, the men from Scandinavia known as the “Northmen”, or Norsemen, began raiding Europe. In 807, they attacked Friesland with a fleet of 200 warships, led by the Danish king Godfrey. They proceed to raid Frankish defenses along the coast, pillaging targets as they please. Monasteries and churches, being the centers of art and wealth, are particularly hard hit.

The attacks are not confined to the lands of the Franks; in the British Isles, the islands of Bangor and Downpatrick, off of Ireland, are faced with continual attacks, and the monasteries on these islands eventually relocate, away from shore. Northumbria is particularly hard hit, and records from this time refer to “dragons” who pillage the countryside.

The reactions of the various lands attacked varies. The Franks suffered the most; Friesa is lost to the Danes in the 850’s. Constant civil wars endanger Nuestria, which is faced with assaults by sea and by land, as the walis, eager for booty and land for their sons, advance north. The war of the Caliph, as the civil war has come to be known, has devastated some of the most valuable estates in the Caliphate; more land must be found, and with the warming trend, Nuestria makes an attractive target. Strongholds fall, one by one, as the Franks come under attack from both directions. The raids cease for a period in the 830’s, as the Danes enter a civil war. Then things worsen, as Horik of Denmark begins having his men attack in fleets. The Danish longboats raid in fleets of warships numbering in the hundreds, attacking Frisia and  conquering it, placing it under the rule of Danish dukes. An attack on Paris by a second fleet of Horik’s nearly sacks the city, but Clovis, the King of the Franks, rallies his people, and they drive the Franks off.


Unfortunately, a few weeks later, another threat appears on the scene: Umar, the jund.

Umar’s origins are clouded in legend. Some say he was descended from Hakam the lawgiver, and his blue eyes and blond hair (distinctive of the Caliphate) attest to this. His opponents would claim he was but the bastard of a Christian, which is also possible. What is known is that he joined a jund in 835, and rapidly rose his way to the top. 

The junds on the frontier were always the way for a young man in the Caliphate to gain fame and fortune, but Umar took it to a new level. He won battle after battle, and songs to his glory were composed by the troubadours of the Caliphate. He represented the epitome of the holy warrior, conquering Christian lands, and returning with slaves and booty. He finally became one of the Wali, and was granted lands around Troyes, in 841. And it was thus that he was placed to deliver the death blow to the Empire of the Franks.

Round after round of civil war had weakened the Empire, and their brief window of opportunity to reconquer France had been lost forever when the Merovignians were overthrown in 810. His army was the largest in the history of a single, mercenary expedition, and with twenty thousand men (according to the chronicles), he besieged, and took, Paris. According to legend, the Emperor entered the Church and was taken up by the Archangel Gabriel, awaiting the day when Paris becomes a Christian city once again.

It was thus that in the Year of 845 that Umar became the Emir of Francia, and the Franks were conquered by their southern brethren.

It is only fair to compare these actions to those of the Caliphate. In 834, Bordeaux is sacked, and we hear reports of the river Bayonne running red, but essentially the country is intact. When the jarl Hastein led a fleet against Andalusia, he sacked Lisboa, and Seville, both cities being unwalled. But at Corboda he found the resistance too strong; four ships were captured, and five hundred of his crew died. Some of the survivors were executed, but others became farmers in the region, selling cheeses to the Sevillanos, and by and by converting to Islam.  (I kept this in from OTL because it’s weird enough to deserve it. Conquering Vikings becoming Muslim dairy farmers, after all, doesn’t happen every day).

Despite what Ibn-Rassan says, meanwhile, the Norse culture is very advanced militarily and technology, and it begins colonizing regions near its homelands. In Ireland, the cities of Cork and Dublin are founded. Trade flourishes in the north, and by and by the Vikings attack the Muslims less often and focus on the other targets. Bordeaux becomes a thriving port, with Irish and English slaves sold there for a handsome profit, in return for Muslim goods.  England is gradually subdued by the Danes, more or less as in OTL.

But Umar is still having problems. With the Caliph’s attention focused on events in the Mediterranean, where the vicious three-way power struggle is ensuing, He is more or less on his own. And more to the point, he is getting old, and is getting tired of defending his new lands from the Vikings. So it was that in 855, when Rainulf of Norway attacks his Emirate, he offers Rainulf a proposal. He will give Rainulf land along the Seine, on the Sleeve, as the Channel is called, in return for two conditions.

 

1)     Rainulf becomes a wali, paying homage to the Caliph and more to the point, the Emir of Francia.

2)     Rainulf becomes Muslim.

Rainulf is obviously in an interesting position. The Muslims are strong, but his reaction to some of their rituals is less than pleasing. But that is such a nice land, and he’s confident his sons could take over the rest of the Emirate, in due time…

On June 4, 855, Rainulf becomes the Muslim Wali of the lands of the Northmans, and swears upon the Koran to obey the Caliph, stating that “On this we stake our very souls”.