Bruno Escapes the Inquisition
by Jeff Provine
Author
says: please note that the opinions expressed in this post do not
necessarily reflect the views of the author(s).
On January 27th 1593,
on this day the Dominican monk Giordano Bruno escaped the Inquisition.
Giordano Bruno was once a highly admired Dominican monk with numerous
publications on the topic of memory, so approved that Pope Pius V had
accepted the dedication of one of his earliest works. As he continued in
his studies and philosophy, however, Bruno became increasingly heretical
toward the accepted dogma of the time. Initially, he simply read banned
works in curiosity, understanding their principles while upholding the
hegemony of the Church. He then delved deeper, creating defenses of
disagreements such as those of Arian about the lower position of Christ
under God and an increasingly pantheistic view of the Universe. These
outrages and the discovery of his hidden copy of a banned work by Erasmus
would eventually cause such uproar that he would flee his monastery and
cast off his habit.
"I'm not sure that the metallurgy and metal-working
of the time would support an Industrial Revolution." - reader's commentsBruno's
life became one of wandering, trying to find a place where a free thinker
may exist. He journeyed to the modern city of Venice, then to Padua, where
he took up his monasticism again, though not joining a monastery, and came
to Geneva, where rumor holds he cavorted with Calvinism. Later, he
traveled to France, where he studied and taught at Toulouse before coming
to Paris under the patronage and protection of the nobles. All during this
time, he wrote and thought and learned, writing essays and comedies about
the way ideas and memories work. Attached to the French ambassador to
England, he came to London and joined new circles of intelligentsia and
began his most controversial works on cosmology, describing a universe
that not only included the Earth revolving around the Sun, but the Sun
being only one of the infinite stars beyond. During anti-French riots,
Bruno left London with the ambassador and began wandering again, teaching
in German universities and being excommunicated by the Lutherans. Finally
he returned to Italy, hoping to teach in Padua (but losing his chair of
mathematics to Galileo) and tutoring privately in Venice to Giovanni
Mocenigo. When Bruno announced he would be moving on, Mocenigo denounced
him to the Venetian Inquisition. He defended his trial well in Venice,
noting that many of the accusations were against points he had made only
in philosophical pondering and did not believe. His few undeniable
heresies against the dogma of the Church, however, prompted Rome to ask
for his transfer, where he may well have been executed as an example of
the increasing questioning of Church cosmology.
"If such thoughts are occuring so early in England,
what of the political impact? Is there the English Civil War still? How
about the Glorious Revolution of 1688?" - reader's commentsWhile
being transferred, Bruno was asked to escape by a mutual friend sent by
John Dee. The famous English philosopher and Hermetic had never met Bruno,
but the two had shared much fascination with the supernatural, and Dee had
taken up several of Bruno's works on the mind in his library. Dee had done
his own travels to Poland and the Continent, where he had lectured for
several courts before finally returning to England to find his library
looted. Looking to rebuild, he sought out Bruno's works and found that the
monk/philosopher/scientist had gone to Venice after attending the
Frankfurt Book Fair. Dee sent a letter and money to invite him back to
England. When found in distress in Italy, the message was expanded as an
invitation to flee. Bruno initially felt that fleeing would be a false
turn for views he felt so true that he would be willing to burn at the
stake for them, but he was persuaded on descriptions of Dee's desire to
work together (though Dee himself was only looking for new copies of
Bruno's books).
"And how do Bruno's escape and subsequent career
affect the Church's later treatment of Galileo?" - reader's commentsNonetheless,
slipping out under the unwatchful eyes of bribed guards, Bruno took a ship
from Venice to London, where he traveled by land to Manchester. Dee and
Bruno struck up a strong friendship as Dee had with seer Edward Kelley
(before the latter had told Dee that the angel Uriel had commanded they
share wives), discussing cosmology and building upon each other's works in
the occult and signs. While generally disliked by the faculty and
administration, Dee acted as Warden of Christ's College and gave Bruno a
chair in mathematics as well as a later position in what would become
psychology. Building a unique curriculum and acting as a magnet for
controversial thinkers all over Europe, Dee would transform Manchester
into one of the most advanced centers of thinking in Europe. Over the next
century, men such as Bacon and Newton would instill great new philosophy,
methods, and technology into reality, such as frozen foods for storage,
substantial memory techniques, focused light for heating and war, and the
capture of steam for work, ushering in the Industrial Revolution circa
1690.
Author
says in reality Bruno was handed over to Rome and underwent a seven-year
trial. He refused to recant in whole, holding many of his ideals (some of
which would be scientifically proven over the next centuries) as fact. Bruno
offered a partial recantation and appealed to Pope Clement VII, but he was
turned over to the Roman authorities and burned at the stake on February 17,
1600. His trial would be seen again a generation later in Galileo?s trial
where science was again halted by dogma. It would be another 289 years
before Bruno would be recognized with a monument upon the spot he was
executed. To view guest historian's comments on this post please visit the
Today in Alternate History web site.
Jeff Provine, Guest Historian of
Today in Alternate History, a Daily Updating Blog of Important Events In
History That Never Occurred Today. Follow us on
Facebook,
Squidoo, Myspace and
Twitter.
Imagine what would be, if history had occurred a bit
differently. Who says it didn't, somewhere? These fictional news items
explore that possibility. Possibilities such as America becoming a Marxist
superpower, aliens influencing human history in the 18th century and Teddy
Roosevelt winning his 3rd term as president abound in this interesting
fictional blog.

Sitemetre
 |