twelve months after Mrs Alexander Hamilton served the
very first dish of ice cream to a thrilled President Washington, her
husband's receipe for the Public Credit was rejected as unpalatable to
Southern States, support deserted the Secretary of the Treasury and his
own piece de la resistance, the Assumption Plan was narrowly voted down by
the US Congress.
As is so often the way with strategic decisions, the technical proposal as
set out in his "Report on Public Credit" made a great deal of sense: the
principle that the federal government should assume at par value the state
debts which were incurred during the Revolution.
Please click the
icon to follow us on Facebook.Detailed financial scrutiny revealed
otherwise: assumption would force the Federal Government to unnecessarily
honour a bad debt. Because some of the States had already negotiated
reduced rates. Moreover it did not appear realistic that former loyalists
could
really be compensated nor that the British Government would
willingly relinquish the Northwestern Forts they still occupied in
contravention to the Treaty of Paris. It was in reality a simple question
over the principles of democracy and republican government, because
surely, central stupidity was endangering local common sense.
Neither commercially naive, nor a "jerk" Hamilton (pictured) had a
powerful ally. Because key to the Presidential agenda was nation-building
both inside the fabric of the former colonies, but also building
infrastructure and establishing respectful peer-to-peer relationships
foreign powers. And so Washington believed that the federal government
would be undermined by individual states negotiating in this way. Better
for his legacy that England and France were forced to deal with a central
contracting authority.
Even though Thomas Jefferson had been deceived into believing the nation
faced bankcruptcy with the Assumption Plan (which actually increased the
likelihood of such an outcome), on this occassion it was James Madison
that changed his mind: "I deserted Colonel Hamilton, or rather Colonel H.
deserted me; in a word, the divergence between us took place from his
wishing to administration, or rather to administer the Government into
what he thought it ought to be..."..
Whilst there was a certain war-time logic to these arguments that sat well
in Washington's orderly, militaristic mind, Hamilton had a broader,
sinister agenda. By promoting the adoption of a "loose constructionist"
interepretation of the Constitition the Federal Government could usurp
powers as it saw fit, and inevitably, the states rights would be
diminished. Assumption was merely the first step on a road map that
included increased taxation, and a Central Bank of the United States. His
receipe wasn't for sweet ice cream, it was a sickening, devil's delight.
Whilst we can only speculate, it seems probable that if the strict
constructionists had lost out, then today the US Government would have
accumulated an unimaginablely large Public Debt that instead of
maintaining the sovereignty of the United States, would in fact mortgage
its childrens future's to foreign powers.